Freedom of Speech

­­

Sadly, the examples below are indeed protected by the freedom of speech clause of the First Amenment. The chants of Jews will not replace us (from Charlottesville) Donald Trump's libelous claims about the Biden family

However, they are not out-of-the-box safe. In 1919, Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, known then and now as the Great Dissenter, gave the opinion that even freedom of speech has limits. His classic suggestion? One cannot shout fire in a crowded theater ...

Federalist 10 (authored by Madison) claims that the “violence of faction” is the “mortal disease” of popular governments. Ironically, it's the 10th Federalist that's most often cited as protecting freedom of speech. As Publius (in this case Madison) points out, the Constitution is designed not only for the American situation of that moment, but also for circumstances most likely to nurture the problem of faction. I.e., infighting among political groups.

Freedom of Speech: Assignment

For each of these well-known cases: the My Lai massacre the Pentagon Papers Rudy Giuliani's ignoring a Congressional subpoena cite what you consider to be the facet of the case most affected by the First Amendment's support for freedom of speech

Freedom of Speech: More Material

Each of the resources below can give you further insight into the relationship between the Federalist Papers, and Freedom of Speech as defined in the First Amendment: Federalists and Free Speech The First Amendment and the Power of Factions Factions and Federalist 10